PokéBase - Pokémon Q&A

Wall for -RisingManectric- (page 128)

I don't see why anyone would downvote your and pk's answers. They were perfectly acceptable.
Jul 29, 2020 by Amethyst
Huh? What're you talking about?
Jul 29, 2020 by Amethyst
Thanks for the support!
Jul 29, 2020 by Amethyst
I wouldn't know what to comment, but thanks for letting me know!
Jul 29, 2020 by Amethyst
Thanks! Y found it, and gave it to me.
Jul 23, 2020 by Amethyst
Hey, sorry for the slow response. The DB server would be displaying incorrect tiers because it's out of date. There isn't a thread for asking Pokemaster to update the server, but we can remind him if it goes on for too long. Has it been like that for a while?
Jul 22, 2020 by Fizz
That’s cool!

And thanks! :)
Jul 17, 2020 by y-chai
Glad to hear it!
Jul 15, 2020 by Fizz
A strict comparison of 252 Def / 252 SpD against 252 HP / 128 Def / 128 SpD will show that for the vast majority of Pokemon, it is an advantage to max HP EVs. However, this does not apply to the same degree for all Pokemon, and for some with extremely uneven HP and Def/SpD base stats, it is indeed better to max both defensive stats than to use any HP. For example, Wailord's very high base 170 HP and very low base 45 defences mean that 252 Def will give it better protection against physical attacks than 252 HP / 128 Def. In general, the higher the Pokemon's HP is compared to its defensive stat, the more worthwhile it is to use EVs in Def and/or SpD -- it just takes a massive outlier like Wailord for it to be *better* outright. The same correlation applies for Pokemon like Shuckle, whose HP is rubbish in comparison to its defences and is therefore much better off investing HP before any defensive stat.
All of the above is pure maths though, and none of it is to say that you shouldn't use HP EVs even in extreme cases like Wailord's. If you have an 'outlier' Pokemon that values extra protection in one defensive stat a lot more than the other (e.g. because one stat is particularly weak), then they might run 252 HP anyway, because it will help with that important stat. An example is Chansey, whose uneven HP and Def clearly fits the bill -- except it will always use 252 HP / 252 Def, because it is already excellent at tanking special attacks.
A long winded response, but hopefully it makes sense. The short answer is you should only use 252 Def / 252 SpD when your Pokemon's HP is much, much better than both its Def and SpD and the Pokemon values its Def and SpD similarly. You can play around with a calculator like this if you're still curious: https://calc.pokemonshowdown.com/
Jul 15, 2020 by Fizz
Hm it could work.
Jul 14, 2020 by y-chai