Which Lunala should I trade?

Question

The Lunala that was Nebby has Decent potential, Sp. Atk, Sp. Def and Defense are Best, HP, Attack and Speed are Decent. The second Lunala you can get from the Cosmog has Outstanding potential, Hp, Sp. Atk, Sp. Def and Speed are Best, Defense is Very good and Attack is Pretty good.

Obviously it's more logical to keep the second Lunala and trade Nebby for a Solgaleo, but I would feel really guilty doing that, I got really attached to it during the story.
Also I wasn't sure if there might be repercussions in game with Lillie if I did trade Nebby.
Sorry for the text wall.

Which should I trade?
Thank you.

Comments

Why trade one when you can keep both? They both have something special about them, after all.

---

I'll trade you my solgaleo for you just give it back to me

---

What is their nature? IVs can change, but Nature is the one thing that never changes, so it is the most important to get right

---

Don't worry, nothing happens if you trade away Nebby.

---

Thank you TheGamingCow289, that would be fantastic! How do we trade?
Thank you everyone else for your help and input, I appreciate it.

---

I'll type my friend code right here: 5343-7605-0249
And you give me yours.

---

It really depends on the IVs. Keep the one with higher IVs.

---

^ please take it to one of your walls, it kind of derails the question

---

We can't answer unless you tell us the natures. Please tell us the natures.

---

Thank you for your help but TheGamingCow289 is going to help with a temp trade so I can keep both, I appreciate you all taking the time to answer my question though!

---

TheGamingCow289, my friend code is 3067-4923-7551.
N the Champion, im sorry but I dont have access to walls for some reason so this is the only place I can do this, I hope thats ok.

---

Oh if that's the case, it's ok lol.

---

Thank you for understanding.

---

You're obviously active enough to check this question, so why don't you tell us their natures?

---

Sure thing, I'm laid up from surgery anyway, hence being able to check this so often. Ok, Nebby's nature is Mild and its characteristic Mischievous, and Luna's nature is Jolly and its characteristic is Somewhat vain.

Answer 1

Lunala's only good use is as a special attacker. Mild increases special attack, and jolly decreases it. Therefore, mild is better on Lunala. Keep the mild Lunala.